How I Helped My Baby Sleep When Sleep Training Was Not Working

sleep training not working

Did you find this blog because you Googled, “How do I get my baby to sleep through the night?”? Well then, my friend, soak in this moment of knowing…this is NOT your magic bullet to deep nourishing sleep. Here is what happened when we figured out our attempts at sleep training were not working.

At Connected Families, we don’t believe in quick fixes. We believe in lasting change. We believe in seeking God’s wisdom, and the hard work that brings rich connection between parent and child.

If you have been part of the Connected Families community for any length of time, you are likely familiar with the Connected Families Framework. During my time with Connected Families I couldn’t help but memorize and internalize these four levels of parent/child connection. I assumed it would come in handy in my parenting journey, but I was not expecting to apply it so early!

Sleep training learned from bloggers was not working for me OR my baby

I’m a first-time, millennial mama. I grew up learning about grace, but I also grew up with fifteen years of classical ballet, an INFJ on the Myers Briggs, and high anxiety. Tada! My motherhood is the potential recipe for neurotic high goals, extreme discipline, dramatic shame, rigid technique, and a confetti of horrific false prophecies for my family. The first four months of postpartum were brutal for me.

I had heard, “Don’t worry. At six weeks, babies kind of normalize.” What kind of unicorn babies were those? I mentally drop kicked countless perky profile pictures in anger after reading, “Two months old and our baby is sleeping through the night!” Thanks, social media.

My reality

When my son Harvey was four months old, my husband Max gently asked me why I responded so urgently if Harvey woke up after a short sleep. I said through tears, “I have worked so [insert profanity here] hard to get him to sleep. If I don’t soothe him instantly, he fully wakes up, and all my efforts were completely worthless.” Max wasn’t concerned by what I had said, but by the pointed bitterness with which I said it. We knew I was not in a healthy place.

This Instagram photo was my reality…

sleep training was not working

I believed Google was my ally. I googled in the afternoon while Harvey cried during naps, and in the middle of the night by the white blue glow of my phone. Loads of mommy bloggers sell a sleep training method, and my literal brain believed there was one for us – 1,2,3 SLEEP!

We tried all the things. But we were inconsistent at best and this only made us all confused. We let him cry it out. We set up a sleepy environment. We laid him in the crib awake. We laid him in the crib asleep. But Harvey was just being his Harvey self and didn’t know I had an agenda. Clearly our idea of sleep training was not working.

In the midst of this season of Google searches, I had a vivid dream. I was living in medieval times, and I was working with a grimey, bearded alchemist to design a sleep potion for Harvey. When Harvey woke me up from the dream at 3AM, I felt so empty. I nursed and rocked him in the dark, and God brought thoughts before me. He reminded me of a king in the Bible who sought magic, and how it only brought him confusion and destruction.

Finally climbing out of the pit

I was convicted that Google is often my “magic”. I realized my generation has few things left that will drive us to seek God. Child rearing is one of them because there is no instant answer. God asked me to stop exhausting myself with Google, to ask for His wisdom, and to get to know this child He has crafted as one of a kind. There is nothing wrong with seeking resources to find some help, but honest conversations with my Creator need to be my first go-to.

Moving forward with prayer, God reminded me of the Four Messages in the Connected Families Framework. With these messages, I am comforted. I feel free to connect with my son instead of becoming resentful, and I hear God’s heart for me as a mom.

IG sleep training not working elsie

During any given 24 hours of parenting, I mentally walk myself through some aspect of the framework:

You are safe with me (especially when you are screaming in the middle of the night.)

Harvey is safe to show his emotions to me. I can find ways to creatively, or practically communicate to him that his bed and bedroom are safe, and that sleep is safe. I can show him that he is safe in the way I respond to his cries. As I enter and leave his room with true peace and relaxed body language, his spirit clearly senses the difference as he calms more quickly.

You are loved no matter what (even when you don’t sleep.)

Even when Harvey doesn’t fall asleep, it doesn’t change my love for him. As I continue to guide him, we can connect and forgive one another for not understanding what the other person is trying to do.

You are called and capable (of sleeping when you need sleep.)

The Lord has programmed Harvey to know how to sleep someday. He is capable of learning. This will happen. In the right timing, it will happen.

You are responsible (for making sweet memories.)

I can’t control what Harvey is feeling or how quickly he falls asleep. Only Harvey can figure that out.

As I write this, Harvey is a fresh seven months old and, although this approach has helped him fall asleep more peacefully, sleep longer stretches, and wake up happier, he still does not sleep through the night. But we have made some sweet memories.

If I hadn’t learned to cue in to him, I probably wouldn’t know that Harvey feels safer sleeping on his stomach (once he was old enough to do this on his own), that he likes his back scratched for a couple of minutes, or that he likes to hold my finger for security while he falls asleep. I wouldn’t have the memories of his head in the crook of my left elbow, his gaze watching my shape in the darkness talk to God with him while his body relaxes to the sway of the rocking chair.

sleep training was not working
Photo by bady abbas on Unsplash

What God is teaching me about sleep and safety

As I pray these new mother prayers, God is also lovingly guiding me to see that I am always safe with Him. He loves me if Harvey sleeps for ten minutes, or ten hours (no, that has never happened). He has made me called and capable as Harvey’s mom. He trusts me to be as responsible I can, and does not expect perfection. With these truths, I can leave behind my feelings of paranoia and shame. I can move forward as a peaceful and confident parent. Even while parenting an infant, I’m establishing the beliefs and habits that will equip me for a connected relationship with my growing son.

*This is a republished article from November 2017. At the time this was written, Elsie Rymer was the publicist and wordsmith at Connected Families. She is currently home taking care of her growing family and her budding photography business. Harvey is now a thriving four-year-old who knows his sleep routine and sleeps really well!


Bedtime battles are exhausting! The routine can last hours. Rather than the sweet connections you were hoping for, the evening ends in frustration and exasperation. It doesn’t need to be that way! Check out our newest resource Transform Bedtime Struggles into Nighttime Snuggles. This thorough and well-researched ebook will walk you through practical and holistic ideas for bringing your child’s body, mind, heart, and spirit into sleep. 

1200 Sleep ebook

Related Posts